Classroom-safe art supply programs for districts, resellers, and procurement teams. Plan a bulk order
Crayola Notes

I Buy Rhodia Notebooks for 80 People — Here's How I Pick the Right One for Each Person

When I took over office purchasing in 2020, I assumed a notebook was a notebook. I ordered the cheapest bulk packs I could find, distributed them to the design and engineering teams, and felt pretty good about saving the company money.

Three weeks later, my inbox had a message from a senior designer that I still remember: "Please don't order these again. My fountain pen bleeds straight through every page." I'd never owned a fountain pen. I had no idea that paper weight and coating mattered. That was the first of several expensive lessons about the fact that there is no single best notebook — only the right notebook for the person using it.

Now I process 70–80 orders a year for a 200-person company across 8 vendors, roughly $150,000 in annual supplies spend. I've learned to stop guessing and start asking a few questions. Here's how I break down the Rhodia lineup based on who's actually going to use it.

The scenario-first approach to choosing a Rhodia notebook

Every time someone requests a notebook, I mentally sort them into one of four buckets:

  • They write with a fountain pen and care about paper performance.
  • They carry their notebook everywhere and need it to survive the trip.
  • They're new to journaling and aren't sure what they even want yet.
  • They have a very specific use case — a particular format, a particular subject.

The recommendations shift significantly depending on which bucket a person falls into. In my opinion, most buying guides skip that step and just tell you "this is the best one," which has never been how purchasing actually works.

Scenario one: you write with a fountain pen (and you're tired of ink showing through)

This is the group that pushed me toward Rhodia in the first place. Rhodia's paper is 80g, pH-neutral, and micro-coated, which is the technical reason it resists feathering and bleeding better than standard office paper. I'm not a chemist, and I'll be honest: I don't fully understand what the coating process actually involves. But I can tell you that our fountain pen users stopped complaining after I switched the order.

For this group, I recommend the Rhodia A5 dot notebook almost every time. The dot grid is the sweet spot — structured enough for meeting notes and sketched diagrams, but not visually heavy the way graph paper can be. The A5 size fits in a laptop bag without feeling cramped. The staplebound version is lighter; the side-stapled version lies flatter on a desk.

I'll be fair: not everyone on my team loves dot grid. One of our engineers only wants graph paper and has told me so, twice, with mild exasperation. That's the honest limitation of any recommendation — paper format is personal.

Scenario two: your notebook travels with you all day

If someone tells me they're commuting, traveling between offices, or hauling a notebook to client sites, I point them toward the Rhodia hardcover notebook. The hardbound cover holds up against being shoved into a backpack or a tote. The elastic closure keeps pages from getting dog-eared, and the binding doesn't crack at the spine the way cheaper softcovers tend to after a few months.

Two of our account managers switched to the hardcover after their third straight replacement order in a year. For them, the extra cost per unit is worth it — I ran the numbers, and replacing a cheap $6 notebook every eight weeks adds up faster than buying a hardcover once every year and a half.

What I'd tell a reader in this scenario: think about how the notebook is carried, not just how it's written in. The cover is doing more work than most people realize.

Scenario three: you're new to journaling and figuring out what a journal even is

Not everyone who asks me for a notebook is a fountain pen devotee. Some people are trying to start a journaling habit and aren't sure where to begin. So, in the simplest terms: a journal is a record of thoughts, observations, or events kept over time. It's different from a planner (which is task-oriented) and a sketchbook (which is visual-first). A journal can be lined, dotted, blank, whatever — the important thing is that it's a recurring space for writing.

For people starting out, I suggest they try the basic A5 dot or lined versions rather than splashing out on something expensive. If the habit sticks after three months, then upgrade to a nicer cover or larger size. If it doesn't stick, you've only lost $12 and not $35. That's a different recommendation from what a lot of stationery blogs would make, but it's more honest to how new habits actually form.

Scenario four: you have a very specific use case

This is where things get interesting. Some requests are for a "western journal" — a journal kept for travel notes, ranch life, outdoor excursions, or the kind of writing that fits more with a rugged, plain-page aesthetic than a structured grid. For those, I'd steer toward the blank-page Rhodia or the 9x14 cm pocket format, which is durable and easy to slip into a jacket pocket.

Other people have specific technical recording needs. We have a handful of clinical consultants and researchers on staff who keep running notes throughout the day — lab values, patient updates, quick references. One of our oncology researchers mentioned that she'll frequently jot down output from a creatinine clearance calculator while reviewing patient data, and she prefers a dot grid because it gives her enough structure to keep numbers aligned without imposing hard lines over her sketches. That's a very different use case from someone sketching product ideas, and it justifies the same notebook for entirely different reasons.

The pattern here is that a single recommendation can serve different needs. The dot grid is doing a lot of work in both scenarios, but the value proposition is different in each.

How to figure out which scenario fits you

When I'm not sure which way to point someone, I ask three questions:

  1. What are you writing with? Fountain pen or fine-tipped pens → prioritize paper performance and go dot or lined. Pencil or ballpoint → any Rhodia format works fine.
  2. Where does the notebook live? Desk only → softcover is fine and lighter. Bag or commute → hardcover.
  3. Are you starting or replacing? Starting a new habit → grab a basic A5 and see if it sticks. Replacing a well-worn one → go up a tier.

If you're still unsure, buy the A5 dot notebook first. It covers more use cases than any other Rhodia format I've ordered, and it gives you enough experience to know what you'd want different the next time. That's been true for about 80% of the people I've ordered for.

The honest limitation: when Rhodia isn't the right call

I recommend Rhodia often, but I'd be doing a bad job if I said it was for everyone. If you're writing with a standard ballpoint pen, you probably won't notice a meaningful difference between Rhodia paper and a $3 composition notebook. That's genuinely fine — paper quality matters most when the writing instrument is sensitive to it.

Also, if budget is the top constraint, tell me early. I've had colleagues insist on a premium notebook and then feel anxious about actually writing in it. A notebook that's too nice can sit unused. In that case, the best notebook is the one you don't mind marking up.

Prices as of January 2025 run roughly $8–15 for the A5 staplebound dot notebook and $18–30 for the hardcover depending on size and where you buy — verify current pricing, since stationery pricing shifts with retailer promotions.

What I've learned after five years of this is that the right question isn't "which Rhodia is best" — it's "which situation are you actually in." Answer that honestly, and the notebook choice gets a lot simpler.

Share this planning note: LinkedIn Facebook WhatsApp
Jamal Carter

Jamal Carter

Jamal Carter is a filing and workplace-organization analyst specializing in binders, file folders, hanging files, sheet protectors, storage boxes, filing cabinets, magazine holders, label makers, and document trays. He references ANSI/BIFMA X5.9 and ISO 9706 while comparing cabinet stability, drawer load, cycle durability, interlock behavior, binder ring alignment, sheet capacity, label adhesion, paper permanence, archival contact, stackability, and retrieval time. His evaluations help records teams, offices, schools, warehouses, and distributors organize active files, archives, shared supplies, mobile workflows, space utilization, retention periods, and replacement inventories.

Leave a Reply